Corresponding author: Karel Halačka ( k.h.hustopece@seznam.cz ) Academic editor: Jolanta Kiełpińska
© 2021 Karel Halačka, Karel Janko, Lukáš Vetešník.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Halačka K, Janko K, Vetešník L (2021) Non-invasive ploidy determination in live fish by measuring erythrocyte size in capillaries. Acta Ichthyologica et Piscatoria 51(3): 275-280. https://doi.org/10.3897/aiep.51.65718
|
Information about ploidy is important in both commercial and conservation aquaculture and fish research. Unfortunately, methods for its determination, such as karyology, determination of the amount of DNA in a cell using microdensitometry or flow cytometry and/or measuring erythrocytes in a blood smear can be stressful or even destructive. Some of these methods are also limited by the relatively large minimum size of the individual being measured. The aim of this study was to test a new low-stress method of determining ploidy by measuring the size of erythrocytes in the capillaries of a fish, including small individuals. First, we examined diploid and triploid loach (Cobitis sp.) and gibel carp, Carassius gibelio (Bloch, 1782), using flow cytometry and blood smears, with these results being used as a control. Subsequently, we measured the size of erythrocytes in the caudal fin capillaries of anesthetized fishes of known ploidy under a light microscope. For both the loaches and gibel carp, direct observation of the mean erythrocyte size in epithelial fin capillaries provided a consistent and reliable determination of ploidy when compared with the controls based on flow cytometry and blood smears. This new method allows for rapid determination of ploidy in living small fish, where collection of tissue using other methods may cause excessive stress or damage. The method outlined here simply requires the measurement of erythrocytes directly in the bloodstream of a live fish, thereby making it possible to determine ploidy without the need for blood sampling. The method described is sufficiently efficient, less demanding on equipment than many other procedures, can be used by relatively inexperienced personnel and has benefits as regards animal welfare, which is especially important for fish production facilities or when dealing with rare or endangered species.
Carassius, Cobitis, erythrocyte, non-invasive measurement, ploidy determination
Polyploidy, the multiplication of whole sets of chromosomes beyond the normal set of two, occurs independently in many groups of fish, from sharks to the higher teleosts. While there are several ways that a polyploid fish can develop, environmental change and hybrid stabilization may play a large role in the initiation of a new polyploid species. Polyploid fish could gain an advantage over diploid fish through increased heterozygosity, the divergence of duplicate genes, and/or increased expression of key physiological proteins (
At the phenotypic level, the effects of polyploidization are often mild and idiosyncratic (
Further, although cell size typically is larger in polyploids, adult size may or may not be altered; as a rough generalization, polyploidization is more likely to increase adult body size in plants and invertebrates than in vertebrates (
Triploidy may be accompanied by morpho-anatomical changes to the organs. Changes may occur not only in proportion but also as anomalies or deformations that have clearly negative impacts on the individual. For example, in fish, negative changes may include gill defects such as missing gill filaments, leading to a reduction in gill surface area, as recorded in triploid Salmo salar by
In addition to possible changes in organ structure, polyploid individuals may also show differences in physiology. Previous studies have tended to focus on differences in metabolism rates between diploid and triploid fish or the ability to survive in oxygen-poor environments. The results of these studies have tended to be ambiguous, however, showing variability within both species and developmental stages, depending on test conditions (e.g.,
Polyploidy is especially common in loach (Cobitis sp.) (
To accurately identify individual biotypes, it is necessary to gradually combine several diagnostic approaches: sequencing of mitochondrial and nuclear markers, allozyme analysis, and cytogenetic tools (e.g., karyotyping and C-banding), including the determination of degrees of ploidy (
Three basic methods were used in the presently reported study to detect polyploidy: i) karyology (e.g.,
In this paper, we present a new method for determining ploidy based on the measurement of erythrocyte size in caudal fin capillaries. The method is non-invasive, suitable for small fish that should not be killed, affordable, and does not require specialized equipment.
For this study, we examined 20 loaches (10× diploid Cobitis elongatoides, 10× triploid C. elongatoides × C. tanaitica; standard length [SL] 6.0–8.5 cm and 20 gibel carp (10× diploid, 10× triploid; SL 1.5–2.5 cm). Ploidy in these individuals was initially determined by flow cytometry (as DNA content using a Partec CCA flow cytometer; dyed with DAPI-CyStain DNA 1-step solution) on a blood sample (loach 2n = 103.6% (96.0–112.0); 3n = 153.8% (142.0–164.4); gibel carp 2n = 97.8% (94.4–104.4); 3n = (154.0% (146.6–162.8)) (
The fish used for measurement of erythrocyte size in caudal fin capillaries were immobilized on the mechanical stage of an Olympus BX50 light microscope using a 36 × 125 mm ‘pad’ with two overlapping tiles glued to the underlying glass (Fig.
The individual being examined was first anesthetized with clove oil (0.05 mL in 1 L of water;
For both the loaches and gibel carp, direct observation of mean erythrocyte size in epithelial fin capillaries provided a consistent and reliable determination of ploidy (Table
Erythrocyte length [μm] for loach (Cobitis sp.) and gibel carp (Carassius gibelio) measured from blood smears and direct from fin capillaries.
Species | Source | 2n | 3n | 2n:3n ratio | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean | Range | SD | Mean | Range | SD | |||
Loach | Smear | 13.8 | 13.1–14.4 | 0.35 | 16.9 | 16.2–17.5 | 0.42 | 1:1.22 |
Capillary | 15.5 | 14.6–16.1 | 0.39 | 19.3 | 18.4–19.8 | 0.43 | 1:1.25 | |
Gibel carp | Smear | 13.2 | 12.7–13.4 | 0.24 | 16.3 | 15.5–17.0 | 0.43 | 1:1.25 |
Capillary | 15.0 | 13.9–15.8 | 0.68 | 17.9 | 16.4–18.9 | 0.54 | 1:1.19 |
The ratio of the mean fin capillary erythrocyte length was similar to that for blood smears, the lower absolute values observed using blood smears most likely being the result of cell shrinkage after drying on the surface of the glass or that larger values obtained using this new method were due to cell deformation (stretching) of the cells by passage through a capillary.
A range of methods have been used to identify polyploid fish; however, each has specific limitations. While chromosome preparation and counting are now considered inexpensive and require little specialized equipment, it is not always easy to perform or successful. Further, while there are exceptions (see
In comparison, the method outlined here simply requires direct measurement of erythrocytes in the bloodstream of a live fish, thereby making it possible to determine ploidy without the need for a blood sample of any kind. Our results indicate that the difference in erythrocyte size between diploid and triploid individuals is perfectly sufficient to reliably determine ploidy. Equipment requirements are limited to a standard optical microscope with a 40× zoom lens and a camera/video attachment allowing an image of the blood cells to be captured and measured. The fish can then be returned to the water after recovering from the anesthetic. Further, the level of stress is relatively low, especially compared to some of the “invasive” methods mentioned above.
The method described is sufficiently efficient, less demanding on equipment than many other procedures (e.g., flow cytometry, microdensitometry), for especially small fish, can be used by relatively inexperienced personnel and has benefits as regards animal welfare, which is especially important for fish production facilities or when dealing with rare or endangered species.
The research was supported by the Czech Science Foundation, Project No. GAČR 17-09807S and 19-21552S. Thanks go to Dr. Kevin Roche for language correction.