Short Communication
Print
Short Communication
First record of the batfish, Halieutaea indica (Actinopterygii: Lophiiformes: Ogcocephalidae), from the Red Sea
expand article infoDaniel Golani, Ronald Fricke§, Brenda Appelbaum-Golani
‡ Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel
§ Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde, Stuttgart, Germany
Open Access

Abstract

The Indian handfish or batfish, Halieutaea indica Annandale et Jenkins, 1910, is recorded for the first time from the Red Sea. This report constitutes also the first record of the family Ogcocephalidae from this region.

Keywords

batfish, Halieutaea indica, handfish, Red Sea

Introduction

The batfishes (Ogcocephalidae) are benthic marine fish species found in tropical and sub-tropical regions. They are found on soft bottoms of the continental slope, most species between 200 and 1000 m depth, while a few species live in shallower waters among rocks or reefs (Bradbury 2003). Their diet includes small snails, small clams and scallops, a variety of worms and small crustaceans, and occasionally small fishes. As far as we know, eggs, larvae, and postlarvae are all pelagic, the postlarvae transparent, globular in shape, sometimes reaching 25 to 30 mm, metamorphosing upon settling to the bottom (Bradbury 2003). Nelson et al. (2016) estimated 78 species in ten genera, but later Prokofiev (2019 and 2020) added another two species. Fricke et al. (2021a) counted 90 valid species in ten genera. The genus Halieutaea Valenciennes, 1837, round batfish or handfishes include eleven valid species with a wide Indo–west Pacific distribution from South Africa east to the Hawaiian Islands, north to southern Japan, south to northern Australia (Prokofiev 2020; Fricke et al. 2021b). It was characterized by Bradbury (1967) as having, among other characters, the disk very flat and rounded, isolated lateral-line organs on ventral surface of tail present, teeth absent from palate, frontal bones forming a groove, but absence of small scales on ventral surface of tail, pupillary opercula, or bucklers.

While sorting old material from the Hebrew University Fish Collection, we were surprised to find a specimen of Batfish belonging to the family of Ogcocephalidae that was collected in February 1958 in the southern Red Sea. Consequently, it was identified as the Indian handfish, Halieutaea indica Annandale et Jenkins, 1910. This report constitutes the first record of this species and family in the Red Sea. The specimen was deposited in the Fish Collection of the Hebrew University (HUJ) and received the catalogue number HUJ 10625.

Materials and methods

Measurements and counts follow Hubbs and Lagler (1947). The vertebrae were counted using an X-ray. The classification follows Fricke et al. (2021b); family authorship follows Van der Laan et al. (2014). Abbreviations used: HUJ = The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel; MNHN = Muséum national d’histoire naturalle, Paris, France; SMNS = Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde in Stuttgart. SL = standard length.

Comparative material. Halieutaea fumosa: SMNS 24740 (1, 68 mm SL), Taiwan, Kueishan Island. Halieutaea indica: MNHN 1986-0004 (1, 82 mm SL), 27 Feb. 1973, depth 445–455 m, Madagascar, 23°36′0′′S, 043°31′1.2′′E; MNHN 1986-0005 (1, 85 mm SL), 2 Feb. 1973, depth 445–455 m, Madagascar, 23°36′0′′S, 043°31′1.2′′E; MNHN 1986-0104 (1, 82 mm SL), 4 Mar. 1973, depth 70–74 m, Madagascar, 25°4′1.2′′S, 047°6′3.6′E. Halieutaea stellata: SMNS 23752 (1), Loyalty Islands, Lifou; SMNS 24623 (1, 135 mm SL), Taiwan, Kueishan Island; SMNS 25863 (2), China; SMNS 25886 (1), China.

Results

Ogcocephalidae Gill, 1893

Halieutaea indica Annandale et Jenkins, 1910 (their figs. 1, 2, and 3)

Halieutaea indica Annandale et Jenkins, 1910: 19, pl. 2 (fig. 4) (Bay of Bengal, off Orissa coast, India).

Lophie faujas Lacepède, 1798: 318, pl. 11 (figs. 2–3) (no locality; appeared as vernacular name only; not available, nomen nudum).

Lophius muricatus Shaw, 1804: 382, pl. 162 (no locality; based on the “Lophie faujas” of Lacepède 1798; not treated as valid after 1900).

Astrocanthus stellatus Swainson, 1839: 331, fig. 108 (no locality stated; based on the “Lophie faujas” of Lacepède, 1798; preoccupied by Lophius stellatus Vahl, 1797 when both are in Halieutaea).

Halieutaea sinica Tchang et Chang, 1964: 156, pl. 1 (figs. 1–3) (Swamei, Guandong Province, China).

Halieutea spicata Smith, 1965: 39, pl. 11 (fig. A) (Isipingo, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, southwestern Indian Ocean).

Material

HUJ 10625, 1 specimen, 77.2 mm SL, Eritrea, Southern Red Sea, Coll. O. Oren, Feb. 1958,

Description of HUJ 10625

Head and body round and depressed, width subequal to length. Upper surface and tail densely covered with broad-base tubercle spines, most of them bicuspid or tricuspid. Ventral surface sparsely covered with minute spinules. Tail round in cross section, its length four times in SL. Mouth with small fine teeth, its width 4.7 in SL. Eyes in dorsal position, their diameter 10.9 times in SL. Interorbital slightly depressed, 6.3 times in SL. Small dorsal fin in posterior position with four rays. Pectoral fins with shape of “elbow” with ten rays well distanced from each other, their length 3.1 times in SL. Prepectoral length 1.5 times in SL. Ventral fins with a single spine and four rays, its length 4.2 times in SL. Preventral distance 2.6 times in SL. 22 vertebrae.

Color

Dorsal surface grayish-brown, spines lighter in color, ventral surface light grayish-beige, pectoral and ventral fins brown.

Discussion

The characters of the Red Sea ogcocephalid specimen well agree with those of Halieutaea indica (see Table. 1).

Table 1.

Measurements and counts of Halieutaea indica (HUJ 10625) from Eritrea, southern Red Sea.

Character Measurement [mm] Count
Total length 90.1
Standard length 77.2
Body width 55.3
Mouth width 16.3
Interorbital 12.1
Distance between gill openings 15.9
Predorsal length 57.2
Prepectoral length 50.8
Prepelvic length 29.8
Snout to gill opening 46.6
Pectoral-fin length 25.6
Pelvic-fin length 18.2
Caudal-fin length 20.0
Distance between pectoral-fin bases 18.8
Distance between pelvic-fin bases 9.0
Dorsal fin 4
Anal fin 4
Pectoral fin 12
Pelvic fin 5
Caudal fin 7

Halieutaea indica was originally described by Annandale and Jenkins (1910: 19, pl. 2 (fig. 4), based on 9 syntypes from the Bay of Bengal, off Orissa coast, India, northeastern Indian Ocean. The species is distinguished from its congeners by having the following combination of characters: broad-based, thorn-like spines on dorsal surface of disc long, closely-spaced, nearly uniform in size; those on tail as long as on disc; underside of disc sparsely covered by small bucklers (broad-based thorns); tooth patches on ceratobranchials-5 with long and pointed inner posterior extension; dorsal surface of disc with irregular patches of pigment or without pattern; pectoral fin unpigmented (Prokofiev 2020).

This taxon was first described and illustrated as “La Lophie Faujas” by Lacepède (1798: 318, pl. 11, figs. 2–3), without a stated locality. The holotype is still extant (MNHN A.4542), but the name is not available, as it was based on a vernacular name only. The first Latinization was the description of Lophius muricatus by Shaw (1804: 382, pl. 162); this name is treated as a nomen oblitum, as it was not treated as valid after 1900, and its priority is reversed in favor of Halieutaea indica Annandale et Jenkins, 1910 (which is here declared a nomen protectum). The subsequent description of Astrocanthus stellatus by Swainson (1839: 331, fig. 108) is a secondary homonym and preoccupied by Lophius stellatus Vahl, 1797 when both are in Halieutaea.

The batfishes (Ogcocephalidae) are marine fish species found in tropical and sub-tropical regions. Nelson et al. (2016) enumerated 78 species in ten genera, but later Prokofiev (2019 and 2020) added another two species. The family Ogcocephalidae was not known hitherto from the Red Sea. The genus Halieutaea Valenciennes, 1837, round batfish or handfishes include eleven valid species with wide Indo–Pacific distribution from south Africa to Japan, Hawaii, and Australia (Prokofiev 2020).

Halieutaea indica has a wide Indo–west Pacific distribution from the western Indian Ocean, South Africa, Seychelles (Smith 1965), and recently recorded from the Gulf of Oman (Owfi et al. 2021) to northern Australia, China (Tchang and Chang 1964) and Japan (Kailola 1987; Kuiter and Tonozuka 2001) (Fig. 3). Halieutaea indica is a demersal species mostly found on muddy substrate to depths of 500 m. It “walks” on the sea floor using its “elbow-shape” pectoral fins. The IUCN Red List designated this species to be in the category of “Least Concern”.

The family Ogcocephalidae was not known hitherto from the Red Sea. Halieutaea indica is apparently very rare in the Red Sea, since in the past six decades no other specimen has been collected. Alternatively, this can also be explained by its occupying a niche that has been rarely sampled. This is an interesting addition to the Red Sea ichthyofauna; this finding illustrates that the fish diversity of the southern Red Sea is still poorly known.

Figure 1. 

Halieutaea indica HUJ 10625, 77.2 mm SL, Eritrea, southern Red Sea. (A) dorsal view, (B) ventral view (photograph: D. Golani).

Figure 2. 

X-ray radiograph of Halieutaea indica, HUJ 10625, 77.2 mm, Eritrea, southern Red Sea. Dorsal view (photograph: I. Aizenberg).

Figure 3. 

Geographical distribution of Halieutaea indica. (A) New record from southern Red Sea. (B) Type locality. (C) Other records based on literature and material in collections.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank Dr. I. Aizenberg, Veterinary Teaching Hospital, Kort School of Veterinary Medicine, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel for providing the X-ray radiograph of the Red Sea specimen of Halieutaea indica. We are grateful to Zouhaira (Zora) Harakati Gabsi for sending us specimens from the Muséum national d’histoire naturelle, Paris, France.

References

  • Annandale N, Jenkins JT (1910) Report on the fishes taken by the Bengal fisheries steamer “Golden Crown.” Part III. Plectognathi and Pediculati. Memoirs of the Indian Museum 3(1): 7–21, pls. 1 (figs. 2–5), 2 (figs. 3–4). https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.13766
  • Bradbury MG (2003) Ogcocephalidae. Pp. 1054–1056. In: Carpenter KE (Ed.) The living marine resources of the Western Central Atlantic. Volume 2: Bony fishes part 1 (Acipenseridae to Grammatidae). FAO species identification guide for fishery purposes and American Society of Ichthyologist and Herpetologists Special Publication No. 5. FAO, Rome.
  • Hubbs CL, Lagler KF (1947) Fishes of the Great Lakes Region. Cranbrook Institute of Science. Michigan, USA, 186 pp.
  • Kailola PJ (1987) The fishes of Papua New Guinea. A revised and annotated checklist. Vol. 1. Myxinidae to Synbranchidae. Research Bulletin No. 41. Department of Fisheries and Marine Resources, Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea, 194 pp.
  • Kuiter RH, Tonozuka T (2001) Pictorial guide to Indonesian reef fishes. Part 1. Eels–Snappers, MuraenidaeLutjanidae. Zoonetics, Australia, 1–302.
  • Lacepède BGE (1798) Histoire naturelle des poissons. Tome 1. Plassan, Paris: 8 + cxlvii + 532 pp., pls. 1–25, 1 table.
  • Owfi F, Zarei F, Sadeghi R, Esmaeili HR (2021) The Indian handfish Halieutaea indica Annandale and Jenkins, 1910 (Lophiphormes: Ogcocephalidae), an additional fish species for the Gulf of Oman. FishTaxa: Journal of Fish Taxonomy 22: 5–12.
  • Prokofiev AM (2020) A new species of Halieutaea (Teleostei: Lophiformes: Ogcocephalidae) with revised identification key for the genus. Munis Entomology and Zoology 15(2): 331–335.
  • Smith JLB (1965) New records and new species of fishes from South Africa, chiefly from Natal. Occasional Papers of the Department of Ichthyology, Rhodes University 4: 27–42, pls. 6–11.
  • Swainson W (1839) On the natural history and classification of fishes, amphibians, and reptiles, or monocardian animals. Volume 2. Longman, Orme, Brown, Green, Longmans, Taylor, London, vi + 452 pp. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.62140
  • Tchang TL, Chang YW (1964) Study on fishes referring to Halieutaea (Oncocephalidae [sic]) of China. Acta Zoologica Sinica 16(1): 155–160. [In Chinese, English summary]